Morning Musume。'19 LOVE Auditon 84 replies to this topic Started by Saya , Jan 02 2019 02:52 PM ·

[JPope]

Here's Mei singing "Wonderful World" in Engrish (DailyMotion, sorry) This is from a year ago, and she's not bad. Raw power and sings mostly in tune. Zero control, but she's pretty young, and control can be learned. She's already several levels ahead of where each of the 12th gens were when they joined. I'm cautiously optimistic. 

[TheParuProject]

Mei was my favorite Hokkaido KSS. She has so much charisma and energy. Not to mention a rather stable singing voice, which says a lot for a KSS.

[Farrah]

All I can do at this point is hope, lol.  I struggle being optimistic but I am glad we got two total newbies.  I've always felt KSS additions to groups were kind of the most boring thing ever haha just because it feels like most of those girls (with a few exceptions) have already been "indoctrinated" with the whole honor student H!P image that is so boring.  I want some girls with rough edges again.

[Anderei]

I feel like there’s a limit to how rough your edges are if you’re auditioning for one of the most mainstream and well established idol groups there is. I think the most H!P gets is girls who are just a bit spoiled.

[Farrah]

I feel like there’s a limit to how rough your edges are if you’re auditioning for one of the most mainstream and well established idol groups there is. I think the most H!P gets is girls who are just a bit spoiled.

 

Oh definitely haha I guess I mean rough edges more in terms of... not having all that idol coaching on how to play the part, you know?  Most KSS just have so much stage experience.  It's exciting to get some girls who are totally green.  I do miss the days when H!P signed girls from more diverse backgrounds, I think that's a huge part of what got them so many big personalities, but I've accepted that they basically only cast rich girls now, haha.

[Revangelis]

Okay, I'm glad they added some new faces, it feels much more interesting than just always adding KSS. I am also happy they did not add someone super young, like 11 or 12.

[Molly]

Homura is a cutie, I hope this freshens up MM.

[AquaChan]

Audition footage is showed in the latest upcoming.

 

I like Kitagawa more and more. 

[Farrah]

Kitagawa’s voice is bland/flat in that way a lot of people’s voices are at that age, but her pitch is really, really good so I’m looking forward to her growth and think she’s a strong addition to the group.

[DonJuan]

What definitely shined through is that neither Homare but especially Rio have been trained by H!P before. Rio still has this light feel to her voice, not the pressing H!P voice teachers seem to enforce.

 

That being said, I like them. They're not tonedeaf and actually have voices that can be worked with.

[Saya]

I was pleasantly surprised with their singing abilities!

[Farrah]

What definitely shined through is that neither Homare but especially Rio have been trained by H!P before. Rio still has this light feel to her voice, not the pressing H!P voice teachers seem to enforce.

That being said, I like them. They're not tonedeaf and actually have voices that can be worked with.

That’s true. There’s a refreshing lack of that pressed, squeaky sound H!P loves so much lol they sound like normal kids that would be in a school choir or something.

[WonderBuono]

Homare is the cutest doll.

Spoiler

(Also Chel’s recording session later in the video was interesting. She kinda struggles on the first take but usually nails it on the second. ❤️ Sorry off topic.)

[Pi Miki]

What. They can actually sing. I really enjoy Kitagawa's voice. I can see this girl being pushed as a front girl big time.

[DonJuan]

I can see all of them getting somewhat close to the front, at least Yokoyan-level, maybe even Ayumi-level (as in, the furthest-away-from-frontgirl-status). The only real weakness that I see right now is Rio's nerves. If she gets tougher then she's definitely front girl material.

 

We haven't seen that much of Mei yet but she seems like a decent allrounder as well.

 

What I'm trying to say is: If management makes the mistake of shoving any of them into the background they're idiots.

[AquaChan]

What I'm trying to say is: If management makes the mistake of shoving any of them into the background they're idiots.

 

I was thinking the same thing: It's sad that they'll get shoved in the back anyway. 

[Banana]

Rio was very nervous, but she has potential for sure. Based on the little that I’ve seen of them, my hope is that Rio will be a strong singer, Mei will be a strong dancer, and Homare will be decent at both singing and dancing. And they’re all really cute. We’ll see how things turn out, but I’m cautiously optimistic.

[JPope]

Kitagawa’s voice is bland/flat in that way a lot of people’s voices are at that age, but her pitch is really, really good so I’m looking forward to her growth and think she’s a strong addition to the group.

 

I thought she actually had a bit of personality to her singing, and I hope they don't beat it out of her. Overall, I'm cautiously optimistic about these two after watching this, and MM should be better in the long run for adding both of them. I think Rio will be the better singer, and Homare the better dancer, but they both look pretty good for raw off-the-street amateurs. 

[Farrah]

 

Kitagawa’s voice is bland/flat in that way a lot of people’s voices are at that age, but her pitch is really, really good so I’m looking forward to her growth and think she’s a strong addition to the group.

 

I thought she actually had a bit of personality to her singing, and I hope they don't beat it out of her. Overall, I'm cautiously optimistic about these two after watching this, and MM should be better in the long run for adding both of them. I think Rio will be the better singer, and Homare the better dancer, but they both look pretty good for raw off-the-street amateurs. 

 

I think there's a lack of emotion and style but that usually comes with age so I'm not worried about it.  It's rare to find girls with really expressive voices that young (in H!P history, Fukuda Asuka, Takahashi Ai and Tanaka Reina are the only ones that come to mind as far as sounding super distinct from day one).

 

I'm so glad we got some fresh kids this time instead of all eggs... I think it's really paying off.  These girls feel like something new.  Now I can only hope they are actually put to correct use!

[JPope]

This is the first time since the 2nd gen that we've seen a multiple-member generation that doesn't include at least one bad singer, and the first ever where we've gotten a straight swap of decent voices (15th gen) for bad voices (the Haruna's).

[Banana]

15th gen’s first singing and dancing lessons in this week’s Upcoming.

[Shoujo Q]

I think Rio has a lot of potential. Homare sounds very typical idol that H!P likes and Mei sounds better than I remember from her kenshuusei tests. It will be interesting to watch them grow as idol singers. 

[Sayu]

This is honestly the first generation since 9th gen that has held any interest for me. I mean, I love Maa-chan but that developed over time. 10th gen as a whole was meh.

I'm actually very surprised that there isn't a bad singer. They're all a bit rough of course and Homare needs work on high notes but I honestly think they can all hold their own within the group. In fact, I actually like their voices. Rio's voice and aura are refreshingly non-idol like and I pray they remain that way. I think she can actually be something if they don't shove her to the back. I mean, really, how many squeaky-voiced moe teens do we need? You can definitely tell that Mei has had a bit of H!P training compared to the others but so far she doesn't seem to have been ruined by it. I hope that keep showing us videos like this.

[JPope]

Homare has a very limited range right now, but when she's in that range, she's not bad.

[TicTacAnyone]

Homare's voice definitely seems like the one that goes into the mic best, so it probably makes it my favorite of the 3 (just as of right now, might change)