Posted 06 November 2018 - 03:36 AM
Thank you Madara for pointing this out. I wouldn't pick exactly the same members as you, but we agree that Mizuki and Sakura are great performers, with real auras (and Sakura can also draw attention just by her dance, she became so good at it). I would say you have to watch them a specifically during the lives to spot Ayumi and Masaki interesting moments, but when she is singing Masaki has also a very strong presence (and when she has the matching facial expressions, her dance makes strong impression). To me Miki can also be surprising when singing, and Maria has something, her energy, smiles and facial emotions gives her a certain kind of aura (when performing, not especially singing like Miki).
I can't say Kaga is a good performer because she lacks energy (her facial expressions have a role in that impression, but not only) and she often doesn't completely finish her dance movements. To me Chisaki also has the same problems with her facial expressions, a lot in MM., less in CG. (And Erina, Haruna and Akane are too weak in dance for me to not notice it.)