Jump to content

  • Please log in to reply
2016 H!P Member Ranking Time to be a Couch Judge Again! 31 replies to this topic Started by Shoujo Q , Dec 09 2016 04:29 AM · 

#1 Shoujo Q

Shoujo Q
  • ( ื▿ ืʃƪ) #1 Sakura Fangirl

Posted 09 December 2016 - 04:29 AM

It's that time of year again! End of year Idol Ranking. 

I linked to the one with the kenshuusei as well if you feel like adding them in. 

Link to the Ranking Sorter - 

http://www.geocities.../mergesort.html (Includes Manaka, Aika and Riho, No new Tsubaki members.)

 

http://www.geocities...mergesortK.html (Includes the Kenshuusei)

 

http://usachan-peace.../sort/sort.html  (No Aika or Riho, but also No New Tsubaki Members)

 

 

Rank is in this order.

Name - '15 (End of Year)-'15-'14-'13-'12

 

 

My New Ranking - 2016 End of Year

  1. 鈴木 愛理 - Suzuki Airi - #1-#2-#2-#1-#2
  2. 小田さくら - Oda Sakura - #2-#1-#1-#2-#15
  3. 山木梨沙 - Yamaki Risa - #7-#25
  4. 船木結 - Funaki Musubu - [NEW]
  5. 宮本 佳林 - Miyamoto Karin - #13-#11-#11-#11
  6. 岡井 千聖 - Okai Chisato - #18-#8-#8-#9-#3
  7. 野中美希 - Nonaka Miki - #10-#26
  8. 佐藤 優樹 - Sato Masaki - #11-#28-#15-#13-#10
  9. 工藤 遥 - Kudo Haruka - #6-#13-#12-#15-#12
  10. 高木 紗友希 -Takagi Sayuki - #9-#7-#17-#21
  11. 梁川奈々美 - Yanagawa Nanami - [NEW]
  12. 藤井梨央 - Fujii Rio - #21
  13. 譜久村 聖 - Fukumura Mizuki- #14-#20-#16-#24-#16
  14. 中西 香菜 - Nakanishi Kana - #8-#22-#21-#25-#19
  15. 石田亜佑美 - Ishida Ayumi-  #26-#12-#14-#12-#13
  16. 相川茉穂 - Aikawa Maho - #39-#44
  17. 佐々木莉佳子 - Sasaki Rikako - #16-#10
  18. 室田瑞希 - Murota Mizuki - #5-#35
  19. 田口夏実 - Taguchi Natsumi - #22
  20. 飯窪 春菜 - Iikubo Haruna - #29-#16-#9-#6-#5
  21. 矢島 舞美 -Yajima Maimi- #19-#22-#19-#20
  22. 尾形春水 - Ogata Haruna - #25-#19
  23. 広瀬彩海 - Hirose Ayaka - #27
  24. 浜浦彩乃 - Hamaura Ayano - #34
  25. 小川麗奈 - Ogawa Rena - #31
  26. 井上玲音 - Inoue Rei - #30
  27. 竹内 朱莉 -Takeuchi Akari- #15-#18-#18-#20-#14
  28. 羽賀朱音 - Haga Akane - #28-#30
  29. 金澤 朋子 - Kanazawa Tomoko - #24-#21-#13-#17
  30. 和田 彩花 - Wada Ayaka- #23-#24-#30-#28-#30
  31. 小関舞 - Ozeki Mai - #17-#39
  32. 宮崎 由加 - Miyazaki Yuka- #33-#23-#20-#18
  33. 森戸知沙希 - Morito Chisaki - #41-#43
  34. 嗣永 桃子 - Tsugunaga Momoko- #32-#29-#29-#14-#23
  35. 中島 早貴 - Nakajima Saki - #35-#32-#23-#23-#26
  36. 生田衣梨奈 - Ikuta Erina- #38-#38-#28-#27-#25
  37. 谷本安美 - Tanimoto Ami - #46
  38. 植村 あかり - Uemura Akari- #40-#31-#26-#26
  39. 和田桜子 - Wada Sakurako - #37
  40. 岸本ゆめの - Kishimoto Yumeno - #42
  41. 上國料萌衣 - Kamikokuryo Moe - [NEW]
  42. 笠原桃奈 - Kasahara Momona - [NEW]
  43. 浅倉樹々- Asakura Kiki - #44
  44. 牧野真莉愛 - Makino Maria - #43-#26
  45. 小片リサ - Ogata Risa - #45
  46. 野村みな美 - Nomura Minami - #36
  47. 山岸理子 - Yamagishi Riko - #48
  48. 萩原 舞 - Hagiwara Mai - #50-#40-#33-#33-#27
  49. 勝田 里奈 - Katsuta Rina- #49-#33-#25-#31-#28
  50. 新沼希空 - Niinuma Kisora - #47
 
 
C-ute - Will forever remain this way. Maimi charms me to no end and I love her to bits but Chisato just sings better and is much more entertaining to watch.
 
  1. 鈴木 愛理 - Suzuki Airi 
  2. 岡井 千聖 - Okai Chisato 
  3. 矢島 舞美 -Yajima Maimi
  4. 中島 早貴 - Nakajima Saki 
  5. 萩原 舞 - Hagiwara Mai 
 
Morning Musume'16 - This, this was a very tough year to end off on. Losing Zukki pretty much tore the pin out of my ranking. I have no solid #2. Miki, Masaki, Haruka and Mizuki pretty much change spots on a daily basis.

  1. 小田さくら - Oda Sakura 
  2. 野中美希 - Nonaka Miki 
  3. 佐藤 優樹 - Sato Masaki
  4. 工藤 遥 - Kudo Haruka
  5. 譜久村 聖 - Fukumura Mizuki
  6. 石田亜佑美 - Ishida Ayumi
  7. 飯窪 春菜 - Iikubo Haruna
  8. 尾形春水 - Ogata Haruna 
  9. 羽賀朱音 - Haga Akane
  10. 生田衣梨奈 - Ikuta Erina
  11. 牧野真莉愛 - Makino Maria 

ANGERME - Losing Kanon and then Meimi. I kind of took out my sadness by ignoring this group. Kana and Maho are basically my rebound idols in this group. Poor Murota, I kind of took out my anger and threw her into the friendzone. 
 
  1. 中西 香菜 - Nakanishi Kana
  2. 相川茉穂 - Aikawa Maho
  3. 佐々木莉佳子 - Sasaki Rikako
  4. 室田瑞希 - Murota Mizuki 
  5. 竹内 朱莉 -Takeuchi Akari
  6. 和田 彩花 - Wada Ayaka
  7. 上國料萌衣 - Kamikokuryo Moe
  8. 笠原桃奈 - Kasahara Momona
  9. 勝田 里奈 - Katsuta Rina
 
Juice=Juice - Karin and Sayuki continue to vex me. I like them both equally. 
 
宮本 佳林 - Miyamoto Karin
高木 紗友希 -Takagi Sayuki
金澤 朋子 - Kanazawa Tomoko
宮崎 由加 - Miyazaki Yuka
植村 あかり - Uemura Akari

Country Girls - Country Girls pretty much took over my Zukki/Kanon/Meimi void this year. I wonder how it will be next year? (My brain is already preparing itself for the lose of Momoko.)

 

  1. 山木梨沙 - Yamaki Risa
  2. 船木結 - Funaki Musubu
  3. 梁川奈々美 - Yanagawa Nanami
  4. 小関舞- Ozeki Mai 
  5. 森戸知沙希 - Morito Chisaki
  6. 嗣永 桃子 - Tsugunaga Momoko

Kobushi Factory - Top three remained unchanged. 

  1.  
  2. 藤井梨央 - Fujii Rio 
  3. 田口夏実 - Taguchi Natsumi
  4. 広瀬彩海 - Hirose Ayaka 
  5. 浜浦彩乃 - Hamaura Ayano
  6. 小川麗奈 - Ogawa Rena 
  7. 井上玲音 - Inoue Rei 
  8. 和田桜子 - Wada Sakurako
  9. 野村みな美 - Nomura Minami 

Tsubaki Factory - Still trying to figure out this group. Visually I like Ami, vocally, Yumeno. But overall I still don't like them all that much. 

 

  1. 谷本安美 - Tanimoto Ami 
  2. 岸本ゆめの - Kishimoto Yumeno 
  3. 浅倉樹々- Asakura Kiki
  4. 小片リサ - Ogata Risa
  5. 山岸理子 - Yamagishi Riko
  6. 秋山眞緒 - Akiyama Mao
  7. 小野田紗栞 - Onoda Saori
  8. 小野瑞歩 - Ono Mizuho
  9. 新沼希空 - Niinuma Kisora 

Groups Overal for '16

 

Kobushi Factory - I was so sure one of the girls would have left by now, crumbled under the pressure, but they stuck together. Very strong start for a rookie group.

Country Girls - Released one of my favorite singles of 2016. Losing Manaka hurt them. I hope they can bounce back next year without Momoko too.

C-ute - I'm going to miss them. C-ute has always been stuck in the middle for me. Love the girls but their songs are really hit or miss for me. Their last single was probably the best I've heard since 2014.

Morning Musume'16 tied with ANGERME - Lack Luster Singles for Me plus, they graduated 2 of my favorite members within days of each other. So Sad.

Juice=Juice - Despite one single and their drama, they were too busy touring to really make a splash with me.

Tsubaki Factory - They are trying. Hopefully, 2017 is good to them, especially with their new members.



#2 Solarblade

Solarblade
  • モーニング娘。

Posted 09 December 2016 - 04:47 AM

I will definitely get to this towards the end of the year for sure, at least after I do my post on my blog, still thinking about it xD

 

Also, offtopic: Q, are ya the same one on Team Cast?



#3 Derby

Derby
  • モーニング娘。

Posted 09 December 2016 - 07:03 AM

I did mine with Riho and Manaka because I wanted to vote for them.

 

From 1 to 8 there are the members who I really like and had a hard time to vote for one or the other. I also like from 9 to 28 and the girls after Taguchi Natsumi are just meh to me.

I don't know the members of Tsubaki at all so the only way I had to vote for them is whose face looks funnier.

 

Rankings within groups:

Morning Musume '16:

1st (#1) 石田亜佑美 - Ishida Ayumi
[-]2nd (#2) 鞘師里保 - Sayashi Riho  :whistling:
[-]3rd (#7) 牧野真莉愛 - Makino Maria
[-]4th (#9) 生田衣梨奈 - Ikuta Erina
[-]5th (#10) 小田さくら - Oda Sakura
[-]6th (#11) 飯窪春菜 - Iikubo Haruna
[-][-]7th (#14) 尾形春水 - Ogata Haruna
[-][-]8th (#15) 佐藤優樹 - Sato Masaki
[-][-]9th (#16) 譜久村聖  - Mizuki Fukumura
[-][-][-]10th (#25) 工藤遥 - Kudo Haruka
[-][-][-]11th (#29) 野中美希 - Nonaka Miki
[-][-][-]12th (#36) 羽賀朱音 - Haga Akane
Maria has come up there because of this single honestly. Her singing sounds awful in Sou Janai but her overall presence has increased. And Ikuta has come up high too thanks to Sexy Cat and Utakata. Haruka experienced the biggest drop as she was like 5th or so last time, I just don't find her that interesting even with her push in Sexy Cat.
 
ANGERME:
1st (#3) 勝田里奈 - Katsuta Rina
[-]2nd (#18) 佐々木莉佳子 - Sasaki Rikako
[-][-]3rd (#22) 竹内朱莉 - Takeuchi Akari
[-][-]4th (#23) 相川茉穂 - Aikawa Maho
[-][-]5th (#24) 和田彩花 - Wada Ayaka
[-][-]6th (#28) 上國料萌衣 - Kamikokuryo Moe
[-][-][-]7th (#30) 中西香菜 - Nakanishi Kana
[-][-][-]8th (#34) 室田瑞希 - Murota Mizuki
[-][-][-][-]9th (#51) 笠原桃奈 - Kasahara Momona

Honestly I haven't really listened to a lot of H!P this year lol. I tried to post something on the songs thread but that just made me realize how little H!P I've listened to this year. I only remember MM songs and not even that, now I'm thinking about the Utakata single and I can't even remember which is the other song besides My Vision (so apparently it is Tokyo, I wasn't even sure if the vision was released in that single or the previous one). What I want to say is that I haven't seen anything from Kasahara, I know I listened to one of their new songs once but I completely forgot about it.

 

Kobushi Factory:

1st (#4) 浜浦彩乃 - Hamaura Ayano
2nd (#5) 広瀬彩海 - Hirose Ayaka
[-]3rd (#13) 井上玲音 - Inoue Rei
[-]4th (#17) 野村みな美 - Nomura Minami
[-][-]5th (#31) 藤井梨央 - Fujii Rio
[-][-]6th (#32) 和田桜子 - Wada Sakurako
[-][-]7th (#39) 田口夏実 - Taguchi Natsumi
[-][-]8th (#42) 小川麗奈 - Ogawa Rena
 
Juice=Juice:
1st (#8) 植村あかり - Uemura Akari
[-]2nd (#19) 宮本佳林 - Miyamoto Karin
[-]3rd (#21) 高木紗友希 - Takagi Sayuki
[-][-]4th (#33) 金澤朋子 - Kanazawa Tomoko
[-][-]5th (#40) 宮崎由加 - Miyazaki Yuka

ºC-ute:
1st (#26) 鈴木愛理 - Suzuki Airi
2nd (#27) 岡井千聖 - Okai Chisato
[-]3rd (#35) 矢島舞美 - Yajima Maimi
[-]4th (#41) 中島早貴 - Nakajima Saki
[-]5th (#44) 萩原舞 - Hagiwara Mai
 

Tsubaki Factory:

1st (#38) 小片リサ - Ogata Risa
[-]2nd (#43) 岸本ゆめの - Kishimoto Yumeno
[-]3rd (#46) 浅倉樹々 - Asakuraka Kiki
[-]4th (#47) 新沼希空 - Niinuma Kisora
[-]5th (#48) 谷本安美 - Tanimoto Ami
[-]6th (#49) 山岸理子- Yamagishi Riko

Country Girls:
1st (#6) 嗣永桃子 - Tsugunaga Momoko
2nd (#12) 稲場愛香 - Inaba Manaka
[-]3rd (#20) 森戸知沙希 - Morito Chisaki
[-]4th (#37) 船木結 - Funaki Musubu
[-][-]5th (#45) 山木梨沙 - Yamaki Risa
[-][-]6th (#50) 梁川奈々美 - Yanagawa Nanami
[-][-][-]7th (#52) 小関舞 - Ozeki Mai

 



#4 Thea

Thea
  • 鞘師里保

Posted 09 December 2016 - 07:07 AM

I was actually waiting for the new year to redo my ranking for when the new ones are added, but I can't miss the BBS one! I'll do another one then.

 

##. Name Name (End of year '15 Rank)

 

01. Sayashi Riho (Same)
02. Takeuchi Akari (Same)
02. Kudou Haruka (30, I was still a bitter bitch, but earlier year ranking was same)
04. Kamikokuryou Moe (N/A)
05. Kishimoto Yumeno (16)
05. Asakura Kiki (43)
07. Fujii Rio (30)
07. Nomura Minami (14)
07. Hamaura Ayano (21)
07. Taguchi Natsumi (11)
07. Wada Sakurako (4)
12. Ogawa Rena (27)
12. Ogata Risa (43)
14. Inoue Rei (28)
15. Yanagawa Nanami (N/A)
16. Nakajima Saki (6)
16. Okai Chisato (5)
18. Fukumura Mizuki (7)
18. Miyamoto Karin (12)
20. Morito Chisaki (21)
21. Nakanishi Kana (28)
22. Sasaki Rikako (21)
23. Niinuma Kisora (30)
24. Yamaki Risa (20)
25. Uemura Akari (13)
26. Haga Akane (3)
27. Inaba Manaka (18)
28. Iikubo Haruna (15)
29. Suzuki Airi (21)
30. Oda Sakura (16)
31. Murota Mizuki (9)
31. Hirose Ayaka (9)
31. Tanimoto Ami (43)
34. Aikawa Maho (37)
35. Yajima Maimi (37)
35. Kasahara Momona (N/A)
35. Ozeki Mai (43)
35. Mitsui Aika (50)
39. Ishida Ayumi (7)
40. Tsugunaga Momoko (50)
41. Katsuta Rina (37)
42. Ikuta Erina (21)
43. Hagiwara Mai (30)
43. Miyazaki Yuka (43)
43. Yamagishi Riko (43)
46. Funaki Musubu (N/A)
47. Ogata Haruna (21)
48. Satou Masaki (37)
48. Wada Ayaka (30)
48. Kanazawa Tomoko (30)
51. Nonaka Miki (37)
52. Makino Maria (37)
52. Takagi Sayuki (43)
 
I'd say that 1~14 is love. Then 15~34 could change all around. 35~52 is dislike to hate, but not necessarily in strict order.
 
Spoiler

 



#5 Shoujo Q

Shoujo Q
  • ( ื▿ ืʃƪ) #1 Sakura Fangirl

Posted 09 December 2016 - 11:33 AM

Also, offtopic: Q, are ya the same one on Team Cast?


Yes, yes I am. O-O

#6 WonderBuono

WonderBuono
  • こぶしファクトリー

Posted 09 December 2016 - 03:45 PM

I actually surprised myself with some of my choices

Bolded names had the biggest change up or down.

 

  1. Suzuki Airi (=)
  2. Tsugunaga Momoko (down 1 [because I didn't use the tie])
  3. Nonaka Miki (=)
  4. Iikubo Haruna (up 1)
  5. Sato Masaki (up 1)
  6. Wada Ayaka (down 3)
  7. Yamaki Risa (down 1)
  8. Takagi Sayuki (up 1)
  9. Morito Chisaki (up 4)
  10. Fukumura Mizuki (up 2)
  11. Nakanishi Kana (down 5)
  12. Oda Sakura (down 3)
  13. Uemura Akari (up 6)
  14. Yanagawa Nanami (new)
  15. Inaba Manaka (down 4)
  16. Yajima Maimi (down 2)
  17. Sayashi Riho (down 2)
  18. Nakajima Saki (up 6)
  19. Sasaki Rikako (down 2)
  20. Ozeki Mai (up 2)
  21. Takeuchi Akari (up 1)
  22. Mitsui Aika (down 6)
  23. Ishida Ayumi (down 6)
  24. Hamaura Ayano (=)
  25. Makino Maria (down 1)
  26. Katsuta Rina (down 2)
  27. Taguchi Natsumi (up 17)
  28. Tanimoto Ami (up 21)
  29. Hirose Ayaka (up 3)
  30. Kanazawa Tomoko (down 2)
  31. Fujii Rio (up 13)
  32. Okai Chisato (up 15)
  33. Funaki Musubu (new)
  34. Miyamoto Karin (down 1)
  35. Murota Mizuki (down 7)
  36. Nomura Minami (down 6)
  37. Kudo Haruka (down 4)
  38. Kamikokuryo Moe (new)
  39. Inoue Rei (down 6)
  40. Ogawa Rena (up 1)
  41. Miyazaki Yuka (down 4)
  42. Hagiwara Mai (down 23; ouch!)
  43. Aikawa Maho (up 1)
  44. Ogata Risa (up 7)
  45. Wada Sakurako (down 12)
  46. Kishimoto Yumeno (down 8)
  47. Kasahara Momona (new)
  48. Ikuta Erina (down 9)
  49. Asakura Kiki (down 1)
  50. Haga Akane (down 11)
  51. Yamagishi Riko (down 10)
  52. Niinuma Kisora (down 3)
  53. Ogata Haruna (down 12)


#7 Solarblade

Solarblade
  • モーニング娘。

Posted 09 December 2016 - 04:11 PM

 

Also, offtopic: Q, are ya the same one on Team Cast?


Yes, yes I am. O-O

 

Oh wowzies, I didn't put two and two together there :D Sweet!~

 

 

Actually I might just do mine tonight and edit the new Momusu members later on



#8 yuzu

yuzu
  • FRUIT UNITY

Posted 09 December 2016 - 05:38 PM

OK I am going to just post this now and romanize and compare later because I am technically really busy at work.  This one I think has actually changed a lot, Maimi has shot way up and Mai shot down.  And of course any tsubaki rankings take with a grain of salt because I don't pay attention to them at all so it was all just based on who they were against.

 

1位   小田さくら  2位   中西 香菜  3位   高木紗友希  4位   矢島 舞美  5位   金澤 朋子  6位   室田 瑞希  7位   小川 麗奈  8位   萩原 舞   9位   佐々木莉佳子 10位   上國料萌衣  11位   生田衣梨奈  12位   浜浦 彩乃  13位   鈴木 愛理  14位   広瀬 彩海  15位   尾形 春水  16位   植村あかり  17位   譜久村 聖  18位   石田亜佑美  19位   和田 彩花  20位   飯窪 春菜  21位   相川 茉穂  22位   工藤 遥   23位   宮本 佳林  24位   井上 玲音  25位   中島 早貴  26位   野中 美希  27位   田口 夏実  28位   牧野真莉愛  29位   野村みな美  30位   藤井 梨央  31位   森戸知沙希  32位   船木 結   33位   梁川奈々美  34位   小関 舞   35位   羽賀 朱音  36位   竹内 朱莉  37位   和田 桜子  38位   山木 梨沙  39位   岸本ゆめの  40位   谷本 安美  41位   宮崎 由加  42位   小片 リサ  43位   山岸 理子  44位   笠原 桃奈  45位   浅倉 樹々  46位   嗣永 桃子  47位   新沼 希空  48位   勝田 里奈  49位   岡井 千聖  50位   佐藤 優樹 
 

 



#9 DonJuan

DonJuan
  • モーニング娘。

Posted 09 December 2016 - 07:58 PM

Will do a full H!P ranking later.

 

Like a lot - like - okay - don't care - go away

 

Morning Musume:

1. Iikubo Haruna

2. Haga Akane

3. Kudo Haruka

4. Oda Sakura

5. Ogata Haruna

6. Ishida Ayumi

7. Nonaka Miki

8. Makino Maria

9. Ikuta Erina

10. Sato Masaki

11. Fukumura Mizuki

 

It's been a rough year for my interest in MM. Since Zukki's grad it's a bit easier to watch them (because I never feel like my oshi doesn't get what she deserves; Akane is a baby that can still grow and Haruna definitely gets her spotlight), but it's also become a bit boring. While I'm "meh" about most of the group, I came to dislike those that I never really liked even more. I know I'm unfair about some things but I honestly do not care. Erina's resting bitchface and her fake cuteness when the camera is on her, Masaki's horrible voice and attitude, Mizuki's blandness in everything. I came to prefer Ogata Haruna over so many members because while she can't sing for her life and is as stiff as a fridge she's cute on stage, she's fun, she's adorable - and I think she's getting really beautiful. Her eyes sparkle. Also, I think she's entertaining. 

Maria is a special case. She's ok. I'm okay with her being build up as another front girl, it's not like Ai was much higher on my list during PE either. I honestly don't mind her because I understand why they're pushing her. But I also honestly don't care about her.

 

°C-ute:

1. Yajima Maimi

2. Nakajima Saki

3. Suzuki Airi

4. Okai Chisato

5. Hagiwara Mai

 

Well, this hasn't changed since I started following °C-ute. I like them all except for Mai, but it's time for them to go. 

Never got into Mai. She's always been that spoiled bitchy child to me. 

 

ANGERME:

1. Takeuchi Akari

2. Aikawa Maho

3. Nakanishi Kana

4. Kamikokuryo Moe

5. Murota Mizuki

6. Wada Ayaka

7. Sasaki Rikako

8. Kasahara Momona

9. Katsuta Rina

 

Moe hit me like a wrecking ball. Damn, she's so damn cute. And she can sing! Kana dropped a bit, but I'm loyal. Momona is a baby so her being 8th doesn't really say anything, I'm sure she'll grow. I've lost hope for Rina though. Boring as heck. She could be the same as Mizuki, but Mizuki at least tries.

 

Juice=Juice

1. Kanazawa Tomoko

2. Miyazaki Yuka

3. Miyamoto Karin

4. Takagi Sayuki

5. Uemura Akari

 

Karin makes her way up. I guess if a group is boring they can at least rely on those that are constantly able to perform well. I'm a bit worried about Sayuki, I prefer my vocalists to not sound like they're dying.

 

Kobushi Factory:

1. Hirose Ayaka

2. Nomura Minami

3. Inoue Rei

4. Hamaura Ayano

5. Taguchi Natsumi

6. Wada Sakurako

7. Fujii Rio

8. Ogawa Rena

 

I knew I'd fall for Kobushi. Rio and Rena are pretty low, but mostly because I don't like their voices. Ayaka might not be the most entertaining member but damn that voice. I really like that it's so rich and that she sounds like she knows what she's doing.

 

Tsubaki Factory:

1. Kishimoto Yumeno

2. Ogata Risa

3. Akiyama Mao

4. Asakura Kiki

5. Onoda Saori

6. Tanimoto Ami

7. Ono Mizuho

8. Yamagishi Riko

9. Niinuma Kisora

 

I guess by now nobody is surprised about me being rather indifferent about Tsubaki. I love Kishimon and I do think Risa is cute. The rest, meh. Riko was a mistake and I just can't deal with Kisora (though I acknowledge that she's one of the better singers in the groups, but I prefer my idols to look like they enjoy themselves).

 

/EDIT: Oh wait I forgot CG haha.

 

Country Girls:

1. Ozeki Mai

2. Funaki Musubu

3. Yanagawa Nanami

4. Yamaki Risa

5. Tsugunaga Momoko

6. Morito Chisaki

 

Another Edit: I totally forgot to give reasons haha.

Ozeko is great. She's not a good singer but she's fun ok. The "newbies" (that don't feel new anymore at all) are amazing, Funaki is oshi material (I think I've said that before). Risa is more than solid, sad to see Momoko go. Chisaki is ok, she's cute.



#10 arcobaleno

arcobaleno
  • 世界をパレードに

Posted 09 December 2016 - 08:31 PM

Here's mine...
 
Usually I don't compare with last year, but I took a goddamn hour to fully confirm what I actually feel like, truly, and for once I have a 100% accurate ranking, so we need to see just how badly thought out last year's was, lol.
 
1. Inaba Manaka [12]
2. Kamikokuryou Moe
3. Nakajima Saki [8]
4. Asakura Kiki [45~50]
5. Haga Akane [1] 
6. Takeuchi Akari [33]
7. Taguchi Natsumi [16]
8. Sayashi Riho [23, but I felt like she was more 15]
9. Iikubo Haruna [13]
10. Wada Sakurako [11]
11. Morito Chisaki [27]
12. Aikawa Maho [28]
13. Tsugunaga Momoko [21]
14. Kishimoto Yumeno [4]
15. Ogawa Rena [18]
16. Nomura Minami [10]
17. Fujii Rio [44]
18. Yajima Maimi [2]
19. Ogata Risa [45~50]
20. Miyamoto Karin [42]
21. Tanimoto Ami [45~50]
22. Hagiwara Mai [26]
23. Nonaka Miki [5]
24. Yamagishi Riko [45~50]
25. Fukumura Mizuki [15]
26. Nakanishi Kana [7]
27. Mitsui Aika [N/A]
28. Wada Ayaka [9]
29. Kudou Haruka [34]
30. Yanagawa Nanami
31. Ogata Haruna [24]
32. Hirose Ayaka [=]
33. Kasahara Momona
34. Makino Maria [39]
35. Ishida Ayumi [20]
36. Suzuki Airi [43]
37. Inoue Rei [38]
38. Hamaura Ayano [40]
39. Okai Chisato [29]
40. Sasaki Rikako [35]
41. Murota Mizuki [3]
42. Ikuta Erina [25]
43. Uemura Akari [17]
44. Niinuma Kisora [45~50]
45. Ozeki Mai [6]
46. Takagi Sayuki [31]
47. Yamaki Risa [14]
48. Kanazawa Tomoko [36]
49. Katsuta Rina [45~50]
50. Funaki Musubu
51. Miyazaki Yuka [30]
52. Satou Masaki [19], Oda Sakura [41]


#11 Thea

Thea
  • 鞘師里保

Posted 09 December 2016 - 08:37 PM

If anyone cares to see the ranking of a fan who isn't on any of the online communities, here is my mother's H!P ranking:

 

Spoiler

 

She loves MM, she likes the rest of the groups but doesn't really know them like she does MM. It's really sad, her existance as a fan, since she can't speak Japanese and doesn't have me to translate MM things anymore, or even talk to about MM anymore. I'm still a bitter bitch, but I DO feel bad about it for her.

 

Edit: I told her what I wrote and she said "Don't worry, I'm over it now."



#12 Derby

Derby
  • モーニング娘。

Posted 09 December 2016 - 10:31 PM

let your mom fangirl with you



#13 Mizura

Mizura
  • ANGERME

Posted 10 December 2016 - 01:04 AM

I had everything all nicely listed and when I posted it, my internet randomly disconnected and it was all lost. I'm listing it again I suppose.

 

Like a lot - like - okay - don't care - go away

 

C-ute

 

  1. Okai Chisato
  2. Suzuki Airi
  3. Nakajima Saki
  4. Haigwara Mai
  5. Yajima Maimi

Morning Musume

 

  1. Ishida Ayumi
  2. Iikubo Haruna
  3. Oda Sakura
  4. Ogata Haruna
  5. Nonaka Miki
  6. Makino Maria
  7. Sato Masaki
  8. Haga Akane
  9. Ikuta Erina
  10. Kudo Haruka
  11. Fukumura Mizuki

 

Angerme

 

  1. Nakanishi Kana
  2. Aikawa Maho
  3. Wada Ayaka
  4. Takuechi Akari
  5. Murota Mizuki
  6. Kamikokuryou Moe
  7. Katsuta Rina
  8. Sasaki Rikako
  9. Kasahara Momona

 

Juice=Juice

 

  1. Takagi Sayuki
  2. Uemura Akari
  3. Miyamoto Karin
  4. Kanazawa Tomoko
  5. Miyazaki Yuka

 

Country Girls

 

  1. Yanagaw Nanami
  2. Ozeki Mai
  3. Yamaki Risa
  4. Funaki Musubu
  5. Tsugunaga Momoko
  6. Morito Chisaki

Kobushi Factory

 

  1. Fujii Rio
  2. Taguchi Natsumi
  3. Nomura Minami
  4. Hirose Ayaka
  5. Hamamura Ayano
  6. Wada Sakurako
  7. Ogawa Rena
  8. Inoue Rei

Tsubaki Factory

 

To be honest, I still can't really rank them that well. I do like Kishimon and Tanimoto Ami. While Asakura Kiki is a good performer, her smile is still super creepy.



#14 Sakebi

Sakebi
  • つばきファクトリー

Posted 10 December 2016 - 01:36 PM

Like a lot - like - okay - don't care - go away

 

C-ute

 

Suzuki Airi

Nakajima Saki

Okai Chisato

Haigwara Mai

Yajima Maimi

 

Morning Musume

 

Oda Sakura

Kudo Haruka

Ishida Ayumi

Iikubo Haruna

Makino Maria

Ikuta Erina

Ogata Haruna

Nonaka Miki

Haga Akane

Sato Masaki

Fukumura Mizuki

 

Angerme

 

Takuechi Akari

Nakanishi Kana

Aikawa Maho

Sasaki Rikako

Murota Mizuki

Kamikokuryou Moe

Katsuta Rina

Wada Ayaka

Kasahara Momona

 

Juice=Juice

 

Miyamoto Karin

v
v
v
v
v
v

Kanazawa Tomoko

Miyazaki Yuka

Takagi Sayuki

Uemura Akari

 

Country Girls

 

Tsugunaga Momoko

Funaki Musubu

Yamaki Risa

Ozeki Mai

Morito Chisaki

Yanagawa Nanami

 

Kobushi Factory

 

Fujii Rio

Wada Sakurako

Taguchi Natsumi

Nomura Minami

Hamamura Ayano

Hirose Ayaka

Ogawa Rena

Inoue Rei

 

Tsubaki Factory

 

Kishimoto Yumeno

Onoda Saori

Akiyama Mao

Ono Mizuho

Tanimoto Ami

Niinuma Kisora

Ogata Risa

Yamagishi Riko

Asakura Kiki

 

 

 


#15 Shoujo Q

Shoujo Q
  • ( ื▿ ืʃƪ) #1 Sakura Fangirl

Posted 10 December 2016 - 03:35 PM

I'm going to rank the KSS. I wanted to wait till the weekend to do it since I basically posted this really late one night and I was too tired to add them in. My ranking is based on who I would most like to see debut, regardless of their abilities because I can only go by what I see in the clips they post on Hello!Station or the other Up-Front Web shows. 

 

 

Please Debut Soon / Could Debut, but needs work / Could Care Less About

 

 

Danbara Ruru - Please just put her somewhere UF. 

Kaga Kaede - See above. They may not be the prettiest idols, but damnit it's what's inside that counts UF! 

Kitagawa Ryo - It's just wishful thinking that she could be amazing. She gives me serious Fujimoto Miki vibes (and Mika). But for all I know she could sound like a tin can in a garbage disposal. 

Kawamura Ayano - I love this Karin clone! And she's a Duu fan too. We already know what a Morning Musume looks like with Karin in it. xD So it's not impossible to see her in a main group or on her own front a new group.

Kiyono Momohime - She gives me vibes of Kago Ai, and you know how much I liked Kago Ai.

Noguchi Kurumi Shades of Nakazawa Yuko, if she ever joined H!P as a kid. (She's even from Osaka!)

Yokoyama Reina- She's cute looking. Visually she's Idol ready.

Kodama Sakiko - Visually she looks ready but that never stopped UF from adding them to a group. 

Takase Kurumi - A former local idol, she' perfectly ready for a group of her own. But I doubt she's front girl material.

Kudo Yume - She looks Idol Ready, but again, have no idea what she sounds like.

Nishida Shiori - She's got a classic idol feel to her, I think she would do well in a group or added to one of the main groups. But I fear she might be a little timid. (Like Akane.)

Maeda Kokoro - Meh. She seems fine but could use with an image change if she debuted. Kind of like Maho. 

Ichioka Reina - Love her to bits, but she's not my favorite singer in the world.

Ota Haruka - Seems nice, but there's nothing really special I see about her.

Kanatsu Mizuki - Cute, kind of reminds me of Kaga. But not sure about her abilities as an idol.

Yoshida Marie - She could debut, but I feel like she might get lost in the group. Kind of like Sakurako

Ono Kotomi - She's got an interesting face but I don't know if that would be enough to not have her get lost in a group.

Yonemura Kirara She needs to grow into her face.  She's creepy right now.

Yamazaki Mei - Suffers from Hagiwara syndrome. Looks way too young and unproven.

Yamazaki Yuhane - Needs to work on her smile. I feel like she'd shank me in my sleep.

Ishiguri Kanami - Nothing special about her stands out to me.
Kawano Minori - While pretty, nothing special about her stands out to me.

Hashisako Rin - Too young.

Inoue Hikaru - She looks like Tsuyoshi Kusanagi with a wig on.

Sato Hikari - Needs Work, a lot of work.

Horie Kizuki - I keep forgetting she's still there. Case in point, I forgot to add her to this list so I put her at the bottom. :D

 



#16 Thea

Thea
  • 鞘師里保

Posted 11 December 2016 - 01:24 AM

I did the Temperature Rank as well! With some slight adjustments:

 

Love - Like a lot - like - okay/don't care - dislike - go away
 
Spoiler

 



#17 arcobaleno

arcobaleno
  • 世界をパレードに

Posted 11 December 2016 - 01:34 AM

Welp,  :bandwagon:

 

Spoiler



#18 Molly

Molly
  • ANGERME

Posted 11 December 2016 - 02:02 AM

Might as well

 

Spoiler



#19 Sayu

Sayu
  • Juice=Juice

Posted 11 December 2016 - 02:18 AM

How are you guys doing color text? I'm on the mobile version which doesn't have any formatting options but even when I switched to the full version of the site, the only extra option is to attach an image. There's no bar with options to change don't size or style or anything like that.

#20 Thea

Thea
  • 鞘師里保

Posted 11 December 2016 - 02:20 AM

I just tested it and on mine, too, even the full version on mobile can't do it. You have to do it on PC.



#21 Sayu

Sayu
  • Juice=Juice

Posted 11 December 2016 - 02:26 AM

:( That really sucks. Unfortunately I only have internet access on my mobile. I guess I'll have to post my ranking as a plain list. Thank you for checking though, Thea!

#22 Ap2000

Ap2000
  • It's a wonderApl life

Posted 11 December 2016 - 10:10 PM

Attached File  Untitled-1.jpg   82.57KB   0 downloads

 

YOU FOCKIN WOT MATE

 

 

EDIT:
They actually ended up being my bottom two. lol



#23 Sayu

Sayu
  • Juice=Juice

Posted 12 December 2016 - 03:16 AM

So my stubborn (determined?) ass decided that I'm doing this anyway. I spent hours writing and then typing out all the code by hand so this had better work. I made a few tweaks of my own. As you can see from my rankings, I'm going to go through some serious idol heartbreak in 2017.

Love - Like a Lot - Like - Okay/Don't care - Dislike - Who even are you?

Spoiler


#24 Thea

Thea
  • 鞘師里保

Posted 12 December 2016 - 03:54 AM

Wow, good job Sayu! I would call that dedication.



#25 Mukuro

Mukuro
  • こぶしファクトリー

Posted 12 December 2016 - 11:57 PM

Doing it like this as well! With a small adjustment to ranking colours
 
The best idol - LoveLike a lot - like - okay/don't care - dislike 
 
ANGERME
 
Takeuchi Akari
Kamikokuryou Moe
Nakanishi Kana
Sasaki Rikako
Murota Mizuki
Aikawa Maho
Kasahara Momona
Katsuta Rina
Wada Ayaka
 
Kobushi Factory
 
Inoue Rei
Nomura Minami
Hamaura Ayano
Ogawa Rena
Hirose Ayaka
Wada Sakurako
Fujii Rio
Taguchi Natsumi
 
Tsubaki Factory
 
Kishimoto Yumeno
Asakura Kiki
Ogata Risa
Niinuma Kisora
Tanimoto Ami
Yamagishi Riko
 
℃-ute
 
Nakajima Saki
Okai Chisato
Suzuki Airi
Yajima Maimi
Hagiwara Mai
 
Country Girls
 
Morito Chisaki
Yamaki Risa
Tsugunaga Momoko
Funaki Musubu
Ozeki Mai
Yanagawa Nanami
 
Juice=Juice
 
Miyamoto Karin
Uemura Akari
Miyazaki Yuka
Kanazawa Tomoko
Takagi Sayuki
 
MM'15
 
Oda Sakura
Ishida Ayumi
Kudou Haruka
Fukumura Mizuki
Ikuta Erina 
Nonaka Miki
Satou Masaki
Makino Maria
Haga Akane
Iikubo Haruna
Ogata Haruna
 


#26 Thea

Thea
  • 鞘師里保

Posted 19 December 2016 - 04:04 AM

This is maybe kind of weird to bring up after so long, so spoiler box within spoiler box!

Spoiler


#27 Shoujo Q

Shoujo Q
  • ( ื▿ ืʃƪ) #1 Sakura Fangirl

Posted 27 December 2016 - 03:07 PM

^You know it's funny in a way. That's how I feel about Angerme right now. I can barely tolerate them even though there's nothing wrong with them. Kanon and Meimi were probably a lot higher in my ranking than I'd like to admit but it's like they ripped something out of me that isn't easy to replace. There are girls I like but not enough to care. Some days I look at Rina with pure disgust, wishing she left instead of Meimi. It hurts more when you know how talented they are and they really don't DO anything after they leave. At least Kanon is writing lyrics, but they aren't really the best songs. So it's kind of a wash.

I felt a bit of the same way when Kago left but it was okay because I just followed her to W, but then the scandal happened and I fell into the Buono bubble and Airi pretty much saved me from leaving all together. When Sakura came along she was pretty much already crowned as her replacement in my mind but I know at this point in time, if no one steps up, I have no replacement for if Sakura leaves. And I'll fall into the black hole of oshilessness.

It also doesn't help that Tsunku isn't 100% there anymore. He's the real reason I'm still here.

#28 TicTacAnyone

TicTacAnyone
  • Danbara's #1 fan

Posted 28 December 2016 - 12:26 AM

Thea, that's how I feel about MM as a whole, especially after 13th gen announcements and Maa-chan being injured. It's like, why even watch or care about them till the lineup changes?

 

I don't hate any of the girls anymore (Ikuta has been better than ever for me this year), but I only really like Maa-chan. So... My rankings for them would pretty much just be irrelevant. 

 

 

Angerme, on the other hand, has a lot of tough choices for me on who I would rank where, as I really like most the girls and the group dynamic as a whole. Even girls I didn't like there I've come to like. So altogether it seems like I've come to like more H!P idols on a general scale, but losing interest in groups at the same time. (MM, Juice, C-ute)

 

If I had to pick my top idols who I'd say are my favorite in H!P right now it'd be Maa-chan, MinaMina or AiAi. If Danbara debuted I'd put it at just her and MinaMina, but she's still in KSS so I don't count her yet.



#29 Thea

Thea
  • 鞘師里保

Posted 28 December 2016 - 02:01 AM

Thanks guys! I really appreciate seeing others like me! 

 

 



#30 Molly

Molly
  • ANGERME

Posted 28 December 2016 - 05:20 AM

I really haven't cared about anything MM has done since Kanon left. I like Maria but she's nowhere close to where Kanon was. And even O. Mai who is my current favorite H!P member isn't on the same level. I will admit Kaga is peaking my interest.