Jump to content

  • Please log in to reply
Morning Musume 20th year anniversary - BBS final ranking It's that time of the decade again 109 replies to this topic Started by Derby , Mar 08 2017 05:16 AM · 

#61 JPope

JPope
  • Dick

Posted 13 March 2017 - 04:19 AM

 

 

 

 

Did everyone always like Kamei? 

 

Yes. She's been wildly popular since she opened up as an H!P News girl.

 

Oh my ranking is pretty accurate. I just meant everyone below 7 is pretty meh tier for me, haha.

 

 

I don't think you meant to quote me. lol!

 

 

Pointing out mistakes admins make should be a bannable offense. :cop:

 

 

I denounce myself.  :suicide:



#62 Derby

Derby
  • モーニング娘。

Posted 13 March 2017 - 04:25 AM

I'm keeping track of the votes but I'll update the ranking tomorrow when Ap's lazy ass decides to finish his list.

I'm honestly surprised at the poor votes Maria has gotten. I know 12ki as a whole is a bit of a bummer but I thought Maria had enough presence and attitude.
Some people gave her only +1 and around that, that's a straight up dislike



#63 Anderei

Anderei
  • つんく♂

Posted 13 March 2017 - 04:39 AM

Not surprising. She's basically Koharu (i.e. useless) but less controversial, which doesn't equate to being terribly well liked. 

 

I'm gonna do this tomorrow.



#64 arcobaleno

arcobaleno
  • 世界をパレードに

Posted 13 March 2017 - 04:59 AM

Some people gave her only +1 and around that, that's a straight up dislike

 

Speaking for myself, having an overly blatant fake crybaby loli-bait burikko is worse than an obnoxiously loud and ditzy ungrateful brat who at least called out the gross part of fandom.  :sick:

 

But also, Derby, he did finish his list!  :tongue: I think the ties are meant to stay as is.



#65 Derby

Derby
  • モーニング娘。

Posted 13 March 2017 - 05:13 AM

I don't know, he said "[list YET TO COME]" at the end of his sentence so I assumed he just used Thea's sorter and then later would rearrange his ranking like Aine did  :lol: if it's not that I don't know what he meant by list yet to come



#66 Myst

Myst
  • ANGERME

Posted 13 March 2017 - 05:49 AM

If we are adding a list of surprises... I'm surprised Yokoyama ended up so high for a lot of people despite being so new. I was surprised where she landed on my own ranking too.

EDIT: Can I be #4BCDD0?

#67 Derby

Derby
  • モーニング娘。

Posted 13 March 2017 - 05:59 AM

I think Kaede and Yokoyama benefited a lot from being new + coming after the failure that 12ki is. If they came after Sakura probably we wouldn't think they're the 2nd coming of Jesus saving us from the Apocalypse.

And yes you can choose any color of your desire. Everyone remember to choose a color or I'll end up changing your +40, +39 and +38 to Kusumi Koharu, Kusumi Koharu and Kusumi Koharu.



#68 JPope

JPope
  • Dick

Posted 13 March 2017 - 06:46 AM

My color is #000000. Just like my soul.



#69 Meikochi

Meikochi
  • ANGERME

Posted 13 March 2017 - 08:14 AM

And yes you can choose any color of your desire. Everyone remember to choose a color or I'll end up changing your +40, +39 and +38 to Kusumi Koharu, Kusumi Koharu and Kusumi Koharu.


Agree about 13kies and please do lol.

I'll post mine on Wednesday at last (will try tomorrow though).

#70 Ap2000

Ap2000
  • It's a wonderApl life

Posted 13 March 2017 - 11:03 AM

Eri is a girl that a lot of people like a lot.
She's very likeable, total waifu material.
 

I'm keeping track of the votes but I'll update the ranking tomorrow when Ap's lazy ass decides to finish his list.


I wasn't aware I had to do anything besides ranking them.
You mean adding the points? I just ranked them with the ranker like Strawberry

Ah, I just forgot to remove the "list yet to come", my oversight.

Edited by Ap2000, 13 March 2017 - 11:11 AM.


#71 Thea

Thea
  • 鞘師里保

Posted 13 March 2017 - 02:00 PM

I think Kaede and Yokoyama benefited a lot from being new + coming after the failure that 12ki is. If they came after Sakura probably we wouldn't think they're the 2nd coming of Jesus saving us from the Apocalypse.

:clap:



#72 DonJuan

DonJuan
  • こぶしファクトリー

Posted 13 March 2017 - 02:16 PM

True. As I mentioned on my ranking I think Yoko won't stay that high (in my list) forever, but at the moment I really like her. She has a nice feel around her.

In general I think current members are difficult to rank. A few years after her graduation Masaki won't be last in my ranking anymore, and new members will take the place of older ones. It's just that I'm more attached to them at the moment.

#73 iDOL1641

iDOL1641
  • こぶしファクトリー

Posted 13 March 2017 - 02:45 PM

40 - Nakazawa Yuko
39 - Linlin

38 - JunJun

37- Abe Natsumi 

36- Goto Maki 

35 - Sayashi Riho

34 - Ishida Ayumi 

33- Ichii Sayaka

32- Kamei Eri 

31- Yoshizawa Hitomi

30 - Fukuda Asuka

29 - Michishige Sayumi

28 -Takahashi Ai

27 - Fujimoto Miki

26 - Kudo Haruka

25 - Nonaka Miki

24 - Oda Sakura

23 - ​Kusumi Koharu 

22 - Ishiikawa Rika

21 - Konno​ Asami

20 - Ogawa Makoto

19 - Makino Maria

18 - Kanon Suzuki

17 - Mitsui Aika

16 - Tsuji Nozomi

15 - Kago Ai

14 - Ishiguro Aya

13 - Yasuda Kei

12 - Kaga Kaede

11 - Kaori Iida

10 - Niigaki Risa

9 - Ikuta Erina

8 - Ikubo Haruna

7 - Ogata Haruna

6 - Sato Masaki

5 - Yaguchi Mari 

4 - Fukumura Mizuki

3 - Tanaka Reina

2 - Yokoyama Reina

1 - Haga Akane

 

I based this off of bias, how much I think they offer/offered to the group, and how much I know them based on stuff I see.

 

And I'll take Kaori Iida's brown #886A08



#74 Revangelis

Revangelis
  • つばきファクトリー

Posted 13 March 2017 - 03:19 PM

1    Niigaki Risa
2    Nakazawa Yuuko
3    Iida Kaori
4    Yasuda Kei
5    Linlin
6    Yaguchi Mari
7    Takahashi Ai
8    Junjun
9    Ishiguro Aya
10    Fukuda Asuka
11    Ogawa Makoto
12    Gotou Maki
13    Kamei Eri
14    Fujimoto Miki
15    Abe Natsumi
16    Ichii Sayaka
17    Tsuji Nozomi
18    Oda Sakura
19    Yoshizawa Hitomi
20    Ishikawa Rika
21    Mitsui Aika
22    Konno Asami
23    Michishige Sayumi
24    Kaga Kaede
25    Kago Ai
26    Tanaka Reina
27    Suzuki Kanon
28    Kudou Haruka
29    Fukumura Mizuki
30    Nonaka Miki
31    Yokoyama Reina
32    Ikuta Erina
33    Sayashi Riho
34    Ishida Ayumi
35    Haga Akane
36    Iikubo Haruna
37    Makino Maria
38    Ogata Haruna
39    Satou Masaki
40    Kusumi Koharu

 

And #8A084B for me~



#75 yuzu

yuzu
  • FRUIT UNITY

Posted 13 March 2017 - 03:20 PM

Did everyone always like Kamei? I don't even remember Yuzu liking Kamei :hahaha:

 

LOL yeah, I was rooting for her to be the sole winner of 6th gen auditions which is why my hate for Reina and former hate for Sayu was so intense  And once she got in she was always in my top three until her grad.



#76 JoshuaJSlone

JoshuaJSlone
  • カントリー・ガールズ

Posted 13 March 2017 - 06:25 PM

#f6e7e1

Pasting direct from the sorter:

1 Yaguchi Mari
2 Tsuji Nozomi
3 Yoshizawa Hitomi
4 Kago Ai
5 Konno Asami
6 Yasuda Kei
7 Linlin
8 Suzuki Kanon
9 Iida Kaori
10 Ogawa Makoto
11 Satou Masaki
12 Kudou Haruka
13 Nakazawa Yuuko
13 Ishikawa Rika
15 Takahashi Ai
16 Niigaki Risa
17 Michishige Sayumi
18 Tanaka Reina
19 Gotou Maki
19 Nonaka Miki
21 Oda Sakura
22 Abe Natsumi
22 Mitsui Aika
22 Ishida Ayumi
25 Fukumura Mizuki
25 Ikuta Erina
25 Sayashi Riho
25 Iikubo Haruna
29 Fujimoto Miki
29 Kamei Eri
31 Junjun
32 Ichii Sayaka
32 Kusumi Koharu
32 Makino Maria
35 Ishiguro Aya
35 Fukuda Asuka
37 Ogata Haruna
37 Haga Akane
37 Kaga Kaede
37 Yokoyama Reina

40 Kago Ai
2 Tsuji Nozomi

Wow, I didn't realize it was possible to separate Tsuji and Kago by that much without smoking and pregnancy!

#77 JPope

JPope
  • Dick

Posted 13 March 2017 - 07:20 PM

1    Niigaki Risa
2    Nakazawa Yuuko
3    Iida Kaori
4    Yasuda Kei
5    Linlin
6    Yaguchi Mari
7    Takahashi Ai
8    Junjun
9    Ishiguro Aya
10    Fukuda Asuka
11    Ogawa Makoto
12    Gotou Maki
13    Kamei Eri
14    Fujimoto Miki
15    Abe Natsumi
16    Ichii Sayaka
17    Tsuji Nozomi
18    Oda Sakura
19    Yoshizawa Hitomi
20    Ishikawa Rika
21    Mitsui Aika
22    Konno Asami
23    Michishige Sayumi
24    Kaga Kaede
25    Kago Ai
26    Tanaka Reina
27    Suzuki Kanon
28    Kudou Haruka
29    Fukumura Mizuki
30    Nonaka Miki
31    Yokoyama Reina
32    Ikuta Erina
33    Sayashi Riho
34    Ishida Ayumi
35    Haga Akane
36    Iikubo Haruna
37    Makino Maria
38    Ogata Haruna
39    Satou Masaki
40    Kusumi Koharu

 

And #8A084B for me~

 

 

#f6e7e1

Pasting direct from the sorter:

1 Yaguchi Mari
2 Tsuji Nozomi
3 Yoshizawa Hitomi
4 Kago Ai
5 Konno Asami
6 Yasuda Kei
7 Linlin
8 Suzuki Kanon
9 Iida Kaori
10 Ogawa Makoto
11 Satou Masaki
12 Kudou Haruka
13 Nakazawa Yuuko
13 Ishikawa Rika
15 Takahashi Ai
16 Niigaki Risa
17 Michishige Sayumi
18 Tanaka Reina
19 Gotou Maki
19 Nonaka Miki
21 Oda Sakura
22 Abe Natsumi
22 Mitsui Aika
22 Ishida Ayumi
25 Fukumura Mizuki
25 Ikuta Erina
25 Sayashi Riho
25 Iikubo Haruna
29 Fujimoto Miki
29 Kamei Eri
31 Junjun
32 Ichii Sayaka
32 Kusumi Koharu
32 Makino Maria
35 Ishiguro Aya
35 Fukuda Asuka
37 Ogata Haruna
37 Haga Akane
37 Kaga Kaede
37 Yokoyama Reina

 

Are you guys ranking in order of best to worst, or are those point values? I feel like you want them to be rankings, but the numbers should reflect points where 40 is best, and 1 is worst.



#78 Revangelis

Revangelis
  • つばきファクトリー

Posted 13 March 2017 - 08:19 PM

 

1    Niigaki Risa
2    Nakazawa Yuuko
3    Iida Kaori
4    Yasuda Kei
5    Linlin
6    Yaguchi Mari
7    Takahashi Ai
8    Junjun
9    Ishiguro Aya
10    Fukuda Asuka
11    Ogawa Makoto
12    Gotou Maki
13    Kamei Eri
14    Fujimoto Miki
15    Abe Natsumi
16    Ichii Sayaka
17    Tsuji Nozomi
18    Oda Sakura
19    Yoshizawa Hitomi
20    Ishikawa Rika
21    Mitsui Aika
22    Konno Asami
23    Michishige Sayumi
24    Kaga Kaede
25    Kago Ai
26    Tanaka Reina
27    Suzuki Kanon
28    Kudou Haruka
29    Fukumura Mizuki
30    Nonaka Miki
31    Yokoyama Reina
32    Ikuta Erina
33    Sayashi Riho
34    Ishida Ayumi
35    Haga Akane
36    Iikubo Haruna
37    Makino Maria
38    Ogata Haruna
39    Satou Masaki
40    Kusumi Koharu

 

And #8A084B for me~

 

 

#f6e7e1

Pasting direct from the sorter:

1 Yaguchi Mari
2 Tsuji Nozomi
3 Yoshizawa Hitomi
4 Kago Ai
5 Konno Asami
6 Yasuda Kei
7 Linlin
8 Suzuki Kanon
9 Iida Kaori
10 Ogawa Makoto
11 Satou Masaki
12 Kudou Haruka
13 Nakazawa Yuuko
13 Ishikawa Rika
15 Takahashi Ai
16 Niigaki Risa
17 Michishige Sayumi
18 Tanaka Reina
19 Gotou Maki
19 Nonaka Miki
21 Oda Sakura
22 Abe Natsumi
22 Mitsui Aika
22 Ishida Ayumi
25 Fukumura Mizuki
25 Ikuta Erina
25 Sayashi Riho
25 Iikubo Haruna
29 Fujimoto Miki
29 Kamei Eri
31 Junjun
32 Ichii Sayaka
32 Kusumi Koharu
32 Makino Maria
35 Ishiguro Aya
35 Fukuda Asuka
37 Ogata Haruna
37 Haga Akane
37 Kaga Kaede
37 Yokoyama Reina

 

Are you guys ranking in order of best to worst, or are those point values? I feel like you want them to be rankings, but the numbers should reflect points where 40 is best, and 1 is worst.

 

Copy pasted straight from the sorter, so they are from best to worst. Can flip the numbers, but it might take a moment as my computer is not currently agreeing with me as much as I'd like -_-

 

edit: managed to get it done, looks a bit wonky, but now it has the points. Computer was in a good mood

40  Niigaki Risa
39    Nakazawa Yuuko
38  Iida Kaori
37   Yasuda Kei
36   Linlin
35   Yaguchi Mari
34   Takahashi Ai
33   Junjun
32  Ishiguro Aya
31    Fukuda Asuka
30    Ogawa Makoto
29   Gotou Maki
28  Kamei Eri
27   Fujimoto Miki
26    Abe Natsumi
25   Ichii Sayaka
24   Tsuji Nozomi
23   Oda Sakura
22  Yoshizawa Hitomi
21    Ishikawa Rika
20  Mitsui Aika
19    Konno Asami
18   Michishige Sayumi
17  Kaga Kaede
16    Kago Ai
15   Tanaka Reina
14   Suzuki Kanon
13  Kudou Haruka
12   Fukumura Mizuki
11    Nonaka Miki
10   Yokoyama Reina
9    Ikuta Erina
8    Sayashi Riho
7   Ishida Ayumi
6    Haga Akane
5    Iikubo Haruna
4   Makino Maria
3    Ogata Haruna
2    Satou Masaki
1    Kusumi Koharu



#79 Derby

Derby
  • モーニング娘。

Posted 13 March 2017 - 08:27 PM

Update in a couple minutes.
Thank you Revangelis though I did flip your votes along joshua's in a .txt

As long as you guys say it's from the sorter I can change the values, you probably don't even need to say it since 12ki and koharu let us know what the bottom is



#80 Mizura

Mizura
  • 賀楓

Posted 13 March 2017 - 08:28 PM

Before I forget, I choose #800080. I can also edit my post if needed.



#81 Derby

Derby
  • モーニング娘。

Posted 13 March 2017 - 08:54 PM

It's alright mizura, your color is already up. And those who don't choose one will have Koharu's original unlucky grey, think about it.

Yoshizawa gets to the top 5, Sayumi surpasses Miki and Kanon drops A LOT, from 5 to 13 while Linlin gets the most points out of this round and goes up 9 places in the rank,
Top 5 points and bottom 5 points.

+195 Linlin
+188 Nakazawa Yuko
+184.5 Takahashi Ai
+179 Kamei Eri
+173.5 Junjun
---
+74.5 Mitsui Aika
+47 Makino Maria
+35.5 Kusumi Koharu
+31.5 Ogata Haruna
+28.5 Haga Akane

at this rate, Koharu could surpass Ogata at some point.
Kanon only got 77.5 points in the last 6 votes, only above Yokoyama and the bottom 5, that's the reason she dropped so much.

Rest of the points from this round if curious.

Spoiler



#82 Mukuro

Mukuro
  • こぶしファクトリー

Posted 13 March 2017 - 09:00 PM

I want this green: #009900



#83 Molly

Molly
  • ANGERME

Posted 14 March 2017 - 03:11 AM

I'm surprised Sayumi is that high??? 

40 Suzuki Kanon
39 Konno Asami
38 Kamei Eri
37 Michishige Sayumi
36 Kaga Kaede
35 Makino Maria
34 Oda Sakura
33 Sayashi Riho
32 Kudou Haruka
31 Kago Ai
30 Tanaka Reina
29 Linlin
28 Gotou Maki
27 Takahashi Ai
26 Yaguchi Mari
25 Fukumura Mizuki
24 Iida Kaori
23 Junjun
22 Nakazawa Yuuko
21 Tsuji Nozomi
20 Satou Masaki
19 Yokoyama Reina
18 Niigaki Risa
17 Fujimoto Miki
16 Ishida Ayumi
15 Abe Natsumi
14 Yasuda Kei
13 Kusumi Koharu
12 Ogata Haruna
11 Haga Akane
10 Nonaka Miki
09 Yoshizawa Hitomi
08 Ogawa Makoto
07 Ichii Sayaka
06 Iikubo Haruna
05 Fukuda Asuka
04 Ishiguro Aya
03 Mitsui Aika
02 Ishikawa Rika
01 Ikuta Erina


#84 aisasami

aisasami
  • モーニング娘。

Posted 14 March 2017 - 12:08 PM

#5882FA please



#85 maryshiin

maryshiin
  • Kenshuusei

Posted 14 March 2017 - 09:13 PM

40 - Takahashi Ai

39 - Nakazawa Yuuko

38 - Kamei Eri

37 - Niigaki Risa

36 - Michishige Sayumi

35 - Yoshizawa Hitomi

34 - Satou Masaki

33 - Iida Kaori

32 - Yasuda Kei

31 - Gotou Maki

30 - Linlin

29 - Suzuki Kanon

28 - Junjun

27 - Ogawa Makoto

26 - Konno Asami

25 - Fujimoto Miki

24 - Mitsui Aika

23 - Tsuji Nozomi

22 - Kago Ai

21 - Oda Sakura

20 - Fukumura Mizuki

19 - Ishikawa Rika

18 - Yaguchi Mari

17 - Ishida Ayumi

16 - Makino Maria

15 - Yakoyama Reina

14 - Fukuda Asuka

13 - Ichii Sayaka

12 - Ishiguro Aya

11 - Ikuta Erina

10 - Kudou Haruka

09 - Iikubo Haruna

08 - Abe Natsumi

07 - Tanaka Reina

06 - Sayashi Riho

05 - Kaga Kaede

04 - Ogata Haruna

03 - Haga Akane

02 - Nonaka Miki

01 - Kusumi Koharu

 

#000099 Can I have this color please ? 


Edited by maryshiin, 14 March 2017 - 09:20 PM.


#86 AquaChan

AquaChan
  • カントリー・ガールズ

Posted 15 March 2017 - 12:34 AM

Can I have this color: #045FB4?



#87 Derby

Derby
  • モーニング娘。

Posted 15 March 2017 - 07:18 AM

It's been a week since this started, so I'm going to have to close it soon.
If you're a little busy and don't have enough time to prepare the ranking just say it now so I know what people I have to wait for.
I know Anderei and Meikochi are supposed to have theirs today.



#88 Shoujo Q

Shoujo Q
  • ( ื▿ ืʃƪ) #1 Sakura Fangirl

Posted 15 March 2017 - 07:57 AM

Shame Madara couldn't join in, I really was curious where Koharu would have gone.

#89 Ap2000

Ap2000
  • It's a wonderApl life

Posted 15 March 2017 - 09:07 AM

Shame Madara couldn't join in, I really was curious where Koharu would have gone.


From very last place to last place.

#90 Derby

Derby
  • モーニング娘。

Posted 15 March 2017 - 10:31 AM

If he notices this and says he'll do it I can wait just like with Anderei and Meikochi. Even if they would post it tomorrow.
I don't mind making it to 10 days or more, I kind of asked on the op how long could I make it in case anyone thought a longer time was needed.

Actually I have to work the ranking on photoshop, so votes can keep coming until the very last minute when I'm done. And I wouldn't be done today anyway.