Jump to content

  • Please log in to reply
2015 H!P Ranking programmed ranker so you don't have to think too hard 39 replies to this topic Started by Anderei , Dec 23 2015 04:02 AM · 

#1 Anderei

Anderei
  • つんく♂

Posted 23 December 2015 - 04:02 AM

http://www.geocities.../mergesort.html

 

With updated photos, so you slacking fans who haven't managed to memorize the bajillion new girls' faces can just go by who you think is cuter. Feel free to post results/complain about how you don't know who half of these people are.

 

It does not include Fukuda Kanon, so you'll have to manually throw her in if she's that important to you.

 

Here are my results (I am absolutely not biased towards a certain group whatsoever):

1. Nakanishi Kana

2. Tamura Meimi

3. Murota Mizuki

4. Aikawa Maho

5. Wada Ayaka

6. Takeuchi Akari

7. Suzuki Kanon

8. Oda Sakura

9. Suzuki Airi

10. Katsuta Rina

11. Sasaki Rikako

12. Iikubo Haruna

13. Okai Chisato (doesn't belong this high)

14. Ikuta Erina

15. Tsugunaga Momoko

16. Ishida Ayumi

17. Yajima Maimi

18. Haga Akane

19. Hirose Ayaka

20. Hamaura Ayano

 

From Chisato on things get crazy because a lot of H!P was boring as hell this year. It gets even more jacked up from beyond this point so I'll just skip to the bottom five. A lot of new girls ranked super low by virtue of not having done much and having super awkward photos.

 

47. Niinuma Kisora

48. Miyazaki Yuka

49. Ogata Risa

50. Kishimoto Yumeno

51. Sato Masaki



#2 freezingkiss

freezingkiss
  • なっきい❤

Posted 23 December 2015 - 04:46 AM

I'll only do my top 10: I'm also not biased at all lol 

 

1. Saki Nakajima

2. Maimi Yajima

3. Airi Suzuki 

3. Chisato Okai

3. Mai Hagiwara

6. Mizuki Fukumura

7. Rina Katsuta

8. Kanon Suzuki

9. Kana Nakanishi 

10. Ayumi Ishida 
10. Haruka Kudo 

 

My last was Aika (second last was Momoko ahaha) , I don't dislike her as much as I used to and I really respect her learning English and reporting so well for Up Front but I just like other members better. 

 

I still call Zukki my MM oshi but it's not surprising Mizuki ranks higher I've been realllly loving her lately. 

 

 



#3 Thea

Thea
  • 鞘師里保

Posted 23 December 2015 - 04:46 AM

01 Sayashi Riho
02 Takeuchi Akari
03 Haga Akane
04 Wada Sakurako
05 Okai Chisato
06 Nakajima Saki
07 Fukumura Mizuki
07 Ishida Ayumi
09 Murota Mizuki
09 Hirose Ayaka
11 Taguchi Natsumi
12 Miyamoto Karin
13 Uemura Akari
14 Nomura Minami
15 Iikubo Haruna
16 Oda Sakura
16 Kishimoto Yumeno
18 Tamura Meimi
18 Inaba Manaka
20 Yamaki Risa
21 Suzuki Airi
21 Ikuta Erina
21 Ogata Haruna
21 Sasaki Rikako
21 Morito Chisaki
21 Hamaura Ayano
27 Ogawa Rena
28 Nakanishi Kana
28 Inoue Rei
30 Hagiwara Mai
30 Suzuki Kanon
30 Kudou Haruka
30 Wada Ayaka
30 Kanazawa Tomoko
30 Fujii Rio
30 Niinuma Kisora
37 Yajima Maimi
37 Satou Masaki
37 Nonaka Miki
37 Makino Maria
37 Katsuta Rina
37 Aikawa Maho
43 Miyazaki Yuka
43 Takagi Sayuki
43 Ozeki Mai
43 Ogata Risa
43 Yamagishi Riko
43 Tanimoto Ami
43 Asakura Kiki
50 Tsugunaga Momoko
50 Mitsui Aika
 
 
I feel like this is extremely accurate up until the 7s, and then.... it just doesn't matter anymore. Everything between 7 and 43 could be in all different places and I wouldn't even notice.


#4 WonderBuono

WonderBuono
  • モーニング娘。

Posted 23 December 2015 - 03:43 PM

Thea I thought you were a Duu fan?



#5 arcobaleno

arcobaleno
  • 夏の楽園でさ迷っている

Posted 23 December 2015 - 04:15 PM

Mine.... I feel like Riho is too low (it only showed her a couple of times though, sigh...), but the rest I can see. There's some things that surprise yet don't surprise me, like Murotan beating out Kananan as my favorite in ANGERME, but while there's SOME parts I'm a tiny bit iff on, the majority is pretty accurate, I think. I only used the "draw" button for the rest of the Tsubaki members + H!P people I don't like since they're all the same to me, lol.

 

Aika was the "real" #39, but I don't count her, so I skipped to Makino Maria, who was after her.

 

Anyway!

 

1. Haga Akane
2. Yajima Maimi
3. Murota Mizuki
4. Kishimoto Yumeno
5. Nonaka Miki
6. Ozeki Mai
7. Nakanishi Kana
8. Nakajima Saki
9. Wada Ayaka
10. Nomura Minami
11. Wada Sakurako
12. Inaba Manaka
13. Iikubo Haruna
14. Yamaki Risa
15. Fukumura Mizuki
Spoiler


#6 Sakebi

Sakebi
  • Juice=Juice

Posted 23 December 2015 - 04:59 PM

Hmm

1. Suzuki Kanon

2. Fujii Rio

3. Takeuchi Akari

4. Ogawa Rena (how did she get up there?)

5. Kudou Haruka

6. Katsuta Rina

7. Oda Sakura

8. Tsugunaga Momoko

9. Hirose Ayaka

10. Nakanishi Kana

11. Nomura Minami

12. Tamura Meimi

13. Nakajima Saki

14. Wada Sakurako

15. Aikawa Maho

16. Kishimoto Yumeno

17. Murota Mizuki

18. Suzuki Airi

19. Taguchi Natsumi

20. Inaba Manakan

 

Bottom 5:

 Fukumura Mizuki

 Ikuta Erina

 Ogata Risa

 Asakura Kiki

 Mitsui Aika

 

Ahhh, these are usually right, but this time it seems wholly inaccurate.


Edited by GaleKakumei, 23 December 2015 - 05:01 PM.


#7 Meikochi

Meikochi
  • ANGERME

Posted 23 December 2015 - 05:20 PM

Thea I thought you were a Duu fan?


Same question here.

#8 yuzu

yuzu
  • FRUIT UNITY

Posted 23 December 2015 - 06:29 PM

First of all this was the hardest matchup I got:

 

Attached File  shit.png   352.57KB   0 downloads

 

Second of all, mine is pretty damn accurate.  Up until 36, then it is like ok Tsubaki and Country Girls who I don't care about, and then my solid bottom six hahaha Only weird intergroup discrepancy I see is that I rank Rena above Ayapan in Kobushi, but close enough

I don't know why but it makes me kind of sad how low MaiMai is slipping in my rankings though...maybe because she was my first favorite H!P kid so I feel like a traitor haha

 

1 Oda Sakura 150p

2 Nakanishi Kana 147p

3 Takagi Sayuki 144p

4 Tamura Meimi 141p

5 Kanazawa Tomoko138p

6 Suzuki Kanon 135p

7 Murota Mizuki 132p

8 Sasaki Rikako 129p

9 Ogata Haruna 126p

10 Hagiwara Mai 123p

11Yajima Maimi 120p

12 Ishida Ayumi 117p

13 Suzuki Airi 114p

14 Uemura Akari 111p

15 Hamaura Ayano 108p

16 Ikuta Erina 105p

17 Wada Ayaka 102p

18 Hirose Ayaka 99p

19 Kudou Haruka 96p

20 Ogawa Rena 93p

21 Nonaka Miki 90p

22 Iikubo Haruna 87p

23 Nakajima Saki 84p

24 Fukumura Mizuki 81p

25 Inaba Manaka 78p

26 Sayashi Riho 75p

27 Makino Maria 72p

28 Miyamoto Karin 69p

29 Taguchi Natsumi 66p

30 Inoue Rei 63p

31 Nomura Minami 60p

32 Takeuchi Akari  57p

33 Fujii Rio 54p

34 Haga Akane 51p

35 Aikawa Maho 48p

36 Wada Sakurako 45p

37 Morito Chisaki 42p

38 Ozeki Mai 39p

39 Kishimoto Yumeno 36p

40 Yamaki Risa 33p

41 Ogata Risa 30p

42 Asakura kiki 27p

43 Niinuma Kisora 24p

44 Yamagishi Riko 21p

45 Tanimoto Ami 18p

46 Miyazaki Yuka 15p

47 Katsuta Rina 12p

48 Tsugunaga Momoko 9p

49 Okai Chisato 6p

50 Mitsui Aika 3p

51 Satou Masaki 0p

 

Wow, look at that ANGERME representation in my top ten.

 


#9 Molly

Molly
  • ANGERME

Posted 23 December 2015 - 06:56 PM

1. Suzuki Kanon 

2. Suzuki Airi

3. Ozeki Mai

4. Makino Maria

5. Oda Sakura

 

1-5 is my God Tier of idols

 

6. Kudo Haruka

7. Murota Mizuki

8. Hirose Ayaka + Wada Sakurako

10. Uemura Akari + Kanazawa Tomoko

12. Tamura Meimi

13. Sayashi Riho

14. Sasaki Rikako

15. Fukumura Mizuki

16. Yamaki Risa

17. Inoue Rei

18. Morito Chisaki

19. Ishida Ayumi

20. Taguchi Natsumi

21. Okai Chisato

22. Wada Ayaka

23. Ogawa Rena

24. Nomura Minami

25. Tsugunaga Momoko

26. Ogata Haruna

27. Aikawa Maho

28. Haga Akane

That's all the idols that I like 

 

After that it's a jumble of everyone else that I'm whatever about and the Tsubaki girls until it gets to the girls I don't like

 

 

44. Inaba Manaka

45. Miyazaki Yuka

46. Iikubo Haruna

47. Nakajima Saki

48. Takeuchi Akari

49. Ikuta Erina

50. Fuji Rio



#10 arcobaleno

arcobaleno
  • 夏の楽園でさ迷っている

Posted 23 December 2015 - 07:01 PM

50. Fuji Rio

 

SOMEONE ELSE LIKE ME



#11 Molly

Molly
  • ANGERME

Posted 23 December 2015 - 07:27 PM

I don't know what it is I just cannot stand her.

#12 Thea

Thea
  • 鞘師里保

Posted 23 December 2015 - 07:54 PM

Thea I thought you were a Duu fan?

 

Thea I thought you were a Duu fan?


Same question here.

 

 

I loved Riho the very day I set eyes on her in 2012. She automatically became a permanent fixture as #1 idol of all time. I loved her more than MM itself. Slowly, my liking for Haruka grew. In 2014 I started to buy her goods, and she started to barely reach the same level of Riho in 2012. She was steadily growing, and I bought more of her stuff. Ls, trading cards, magazine clippings, a towel. I liked her as the companion to my Riho love. Then Riho announced her graduation two months ago. Within the first month I was like "At least I have Duu," but then at the turning point, in the last few weeks, I've become disgusted with her, wondering why I ever liked her or thought she was pretty, and I avoid looking at her, like I avoid the rest (but a little bit more). One reason is this girly thing she's starting now, and because they're pushing her to become one of the next centers, and fill the hole that to me should never be filled. So no, I don't like Kudou anymore. I was about to throw away everything I had accumulated but my mother saved it by taking it. And my friend took the one towel.

 

TL;DR Without Riho, she's shit to me. (Like almost all of MM)

 

But thanks for noticing and caring, I appreciate it.  :heart:



#13 Mizura

Mizura
  • ANGERME

Posted 23 December 2015 - 08:35 PM

  1. Nakanishi Kana
  2. Wada Ayaka
  3. Katsuta Rina
  4. Oda Sakura
  5. Ishida Ayumi
  6. Takagi Sayuki
  7. Tamura Meimi
  8. Sayashi Riho
  9. Ogata Haruna
  10. Nonaka Miki
  11. Aikawa Maho
  12. Murota Mizuki
  13. Haga Akane
  14. Sasaki Rikako
  15. Fujii Rio
  16. Suzuki Kanon
  17. Ozeki Mai
  18. Takeuchi Akari
  19. Morito Chisaki 
  20. Okai Chisato
  21. Iikubo Haruna
  22. Suzuki Airi
  23. Hagiwara Mai
  24. Taguchi Natsumi
  25. Yamaki Risa
  26. Uemura Akari
  27. Hirose Ayaka
  28. Kudo Haruka
  29. Wada Sakurako
  30. Inoue Rei
  31. Nomura Minami
  32. Inaba Manaka
  33. Sato Masaki
  34. Hamaura Ayano
  35. Nakajima Saki
  36. Tsugunaga Momoko
  37. Ogawa Rena
  38. Yajima Maimi
  39. Makino Maria
  40. Ikuta Erina
  41. Fukumura Mizuki
  42. Kanazawa Tomoko
  43. Miyazaki Yuka
  44. Miyamoto Karin
  45. Mitsui Aika
  46. Kishimoto Yumeno
  47. Yamagishi Riko
  48. Ogata Risa
  49. Niinuma Kisora
  50. Tanimoto Ami
  51. Asakura Kiki

 

I have Angerme bias as well. For the most part, I don't know how accurate the middle rankings are. But the ending rankings are accurate. Aika doesn't do anything and Tsubaki Factory has yet to do something good.



#14 WonderBuono

WonderBuono
  • モーニング娘。

Posted 23 December 2015 - 09:19 PM

Well I did mine. As always I gave up trying halfway through and started selecting "tie" for most of them. Oh well.

 

Top 10 in bold.

 

1. Suzuki Airi

1. Tsugunaga Momoko 

(Buono! bias)

3. Nonaka Miki

3. Wada Ayaka

5. Iikubo Haruna

6. Sato Masaki

6. Nakanishi Kana

6. Yamaki Risa

9. Oda Sakura

9. Takagi Sayuki

11. Inaba Manaka

12. Fukumura Mizuki

13. Morito Chisaki

14. Yajima Maimi

15. Sayashi Riho (I feel like she should be a little higher)

16. Mitsui Aika

17. Ishida Ayumi

17. Sasaki Rikako

19. Hagiwara Mai

19. Suzuki Kanon

19. Uemura Akari

22. Takeuchi Akari

22. Ozeki Mai

24. Nakajima Saki

24. Makino Maria

24. Katsuta Rina

24. Hamaura Ayano

28. Murota Mizuki

28. Kanazawa Tomoko

30. Tamura Meimi

30. Nomura Minami

32. Hirose Ayaka

33. Kudo Haruka

33. Miyamoto Karin

33. Wada Sakurako

33. Inoue Rei

37. Miyazaki Yuka

38. Kishimoto Yumeno

39. Ikuta Erina

39. Haga Akane

41. Ogata Haruna

41. Ogawa Rena

41. Yamagishi Riko

44. Aikawa Maho

44. Fujii Rio

44. Taguchi Natsumi

47. Okai Chisato

48. Asakura Kiki

49. Niinuma Kisora

49. Tanimoto Ami

51. Ogata Risa



#15 TicTacAnyone

TicTacAnyone
  • Danbara's #1 fan

Posted 23 December 2015 - 11:02 PM

(Tried to match the same colors they use on their guide thing but oh well lol)

 

1. Nonaka Miki

2. Iikubo Haruna

3. Sato Masaki

4. Hirose Ayaka

5. Murota Mizuki

6. Kudo Haruka

7. Suzuki Airi

8. Oda Sakura

9. Sayashi Riho

10. Ishida Ayumi

11. Ogawa Rena

12. Miyamoto Karin

13. Makino Maria

-----------

45. Niinuma Kisora

46. Okai Chisato

47. Ogata Risa

48. Kishimoto Yumeno

49. Fujii Rio

50. Mitsui Aika

51. Yamagishi Riko

 

Pretty accurate, no complaints here. I don't think Kudo is actually that high but whatevs, lol.  You guys aren't alone in your dislike of Fujii btw, hahahaha.



#16 Thea

Thea
  • 鞘師里保

Posted 23 December 2015 - 11:44 PM

I think I overused the tie button, so I redid it, and only used it thrice.

01 Sayashi Riho
02 Takeuchi Akari
03 Haga Akane
04 Wada Sakurako
05 Okai Chisato
06 Nakajima Saki
07 Nomura Minami
08 Fukumura Mizuki
09 Ishida Ayumi
10 Oda Sakura
11 Miyamoto Karin
11 Uemura Akari
13 Iikubo Haruna
14 Murota Mizuki
15 Hirose Ayaka
16 Ogawa Rena
17 Tamura Meimi
18 Taguchi Natsumi
19 Ikuta Erina
20 Inaba Manaka
21 Ogata Haruna
22 Nakanishi Kana
23 Hamaura Ayano
24 Morito Chisaki
25 Wasa Ayaka
26 Suzuki Airi
27 Inoue Rei
28 Nonaka Miki
29 Kudou Haruka
30 Yamaki Risa
31 Fujii Rio
32 Sasaki Rikako
33 Aikawa Maho
34 Kishimoto Yumeno
35 Yajima Maimi
36 Satou Masaki
37 Hagiwara Mai
38 Makino Maria
39 Kanazawa Tomoko
40 Ogata Risa
41 Ozeki Mai
42 Suzuki Kanon
43 Katsuta Rina
44 Tanimoto Ami
45 Miyazaki Yuka
46 Tsugunaga Momoko
47 Yamagishi Riko
47 Niinuma Kisora
49 Asakura Kiki
50 Takagi Sayuki
50 Mitsui Aika

This one is a lot more accurate.

#17 Derby

Derby
  • モーニング娘。

Posted 24 December 2015 - 02:52 AM

Instead of writing all the names I thought it would be a lot easier taking to screencaps so my top is:

(I want to add Maro, she would be between Sakura and Ayano)

Spoiler



#18 freezingkiss

freezingkiss
  • なっきい❤

Posted 24 December 2015 - 03:35 AM

 

Thea I thought you were a Duu fan?

 

Thea I thought you were a Duu fan?


Same question here.

 

 

 

TL;DR Without Riho, she's shit to me. (Like almost all of MM)

 

 

 

This is really harsh dude. When I saw MM she stood out to me and I think she actually shot up in my rankings. I don't know what would make you dislike a member this hard when they haven't really changed at all? Give her another shot she's still the same ol Duu



#19 Thea

Thea
  • 鞘師里保

Posted 24 December 2015 - 05:48 AM

She has changed, actually. But besides that, I just don't like current era MM anymore, it's not like it's anything personal. It's only hitting her the hardest, most noticeably, because she was my next favorite.

#20 Sakebi

Sakebi
  • Juice=Juice

Posted 24 December 2015 - 12:48 PM

One day you guys will accept Rio as the goddess she is, until then I'll keep that bundle of cuteness to myself.

^If thats the reaction you got for that, I really should keep my opinions of Kanon to myself lol. I know what you mean though, sometimes they are nicer in pairs, I would probably stop liking Kumai if Maasa graduated before her.



#21 showraniy

showraniy
  • ANGERME

Posted 24 December 2015 - 05:06 PM

That whole line of thinking is alien to me, and incredibly off-putting.

Is this the way wota think??

#22 Sakebi

Sakebi
  • Juice=Juice

Posted 24 December 2015 - 05:33 PM

Not necessarily, it's more or less like a personality test or organizer. No one bases their favorites on it, they just want to see how their favorites stack up in comparison to other girls in their personal pool. 

 

I also re-did mine since I think I made the same mistake as Thea. I think I tied once,

 

1) Suzuki Kanon

2) Takeuchi Akari

3) Fujii Rio

4) Nakanishi Kana

5) Oda Sakura

6) Kudo Haruka

7) Kishimoto Yumeno

8) Tsugunaga Momoko

9) Miyamoto Karin

10) Hirose Ayaka

11) Inaba Manaka

12) Katsuta Rina

13) Murota Mizuki

14) Nomura Minami

15) Sasaki RIkako

16) Nakajima Saki

17) Tamura Meimi

18) Wada Sakurako

19) Ogawa Rena

20) Tanimoto Ami

 

. . .

 

47) Ikuta Erina

47) Ogata Risa

49) Uemura Akari

50) Asakura Kiki

51) Fukumura Mizuki

 

This seems a lot more accurate.


Edited by GaleKakumei, 24 December 2015 - 05:35 PM.


#23 Anderei

Anderei
  • つんく♂

Posted 24 December 2015 - 05:34 PM

^^It's common in Japan to have one girl as your favorite way above the rest but even most of them seem to just move to another girl once someone is gone, which is why just one person leaving never really seems to affect sales that much. I highly doubt most of them feel THAT strongly about Riho. They'll just get a new favorite and life will go on.

#24 showraniy

showraniy
  • ANGERME

Posted 24 December 2015 - 06:49 PM

Sorry, Kakumei, I was referring to Thea's posts on Haruka; I should've quoted her to be clearer.

^^It's common in Japan to have one girl as your favorite way above the rest but even most of them seem to just move to another girl once someone is gone, which is why just one person leaving never really seems to affect sales that much. I highly doubt most of them feel THAT strongly about Riho. They'll just get a new favorite and life will go on.

Even so, I remember pictures of Fujimoto Miki CDs all shattered with "Congratulations on you marriage" scribbled over them or something right after that whole "scandal," and I guess I just wonder if those types of fans are more common than I'd like to believe. It seems to involve a really personal level of rage regarding the idols, and it strikes me as very odd to put it simply.

#25 Mukuro

Mukuro
  • モーニング娘。

Posted 24 December 2015 - 07:21 PM

I'm going to compare mine to earlier this year before I knew any of the new girls. 
 
1.Suzuki Kanon [stayed]
2. Aikawa Maho [39]
3. Inoue Rei [NEW]
4. Ishida Ayumi [5]
5. Kudo Haruka [4]
6. Takeuchi Akari [2]
7. Oda Sakura [3]
8. Tamura Meimi [same]
9. Murota Mizuki [28]
10. Sasaki Rikako [31]
11. Hamaura Ayano [NEW]

12. Sato Masaki [26]

13. Sayashi Riho [14]

14. Nonaka Miki [23]

15. Inaba Manaka [below 40]

16. Fukumura Mizuki [15]

17. Makino Maria

 

At this point I forget how to spell everyone's names/ I don't care as much.

 

 



#26 Thea

Thea
  • 鞘師里保

Posted 24 December 2015 - 07:21 PM

I'm special. 8o No, not really. I think there are a number of fans that feel this way, but not so many that it affects sales, or is even really noticeable.But I seem to recall that a lot of fans quit/dropped out when Sayu graduated, right? That were her fans from the very beginning? So I think it's akin to that. It's just that mine lasted 5 years instead of 11.



#27 Sakebi

Sakebi
  • Juice=Juice

Posted 24 December 2015 - 07:45 PM

I'm one of them too lol, I really, really dislike Morning Musume (at first I just didn't have interest in them, but the obligatory support is getting to me lol), I stick around for Kanon, once she is gone, I am gone. I like the girls, but I'm not attached to them at all, and I don't like their music or choreography. I skipped out on the New York concert just because I expected Kanon to not get a lot of spotlight.


Edited by GaleKakumei, 24 December 2015 - 07:50 PM.


#28 JPope

JPope
  • Dick

Posted 24 December 2015 - 07:49 PM

Without Riho, I'm stoked to see Kudo have even more space to grow. Her big opportunity has arrived.



#29 phancy

phancy
  • Kenshuusei

Posted 24 December 2015 - 08:28 PM

Even so, I remember pictures of Fujimoto Miki CDs all shattered with "Congratulations on you marriage" scribbled over them or something right after that whole "scandal," and I guess I just wonder if those types of fans are more common than I'd like to believe. It seems to involve a really personal level of rage regarding the idols, and it strikes me as very odd to put it simply.

 
Scandals are betrayment to fans, they have the right to be frustrated. Mikitti's wotas were pretty hardcore, I would expect more than shattered CDs.

Here's my ranking, I'm pretty much a shitty DD so it's just an indicator of girls I like a little more than the others, but I don't have oshis.

Spoiler


Edited by phancy, 24 December 2015 - 10:27 PM.


#30 Solarblade

Solarblade
  • ANGERME

Posted 24 December 2015 - 08:37 PM

Dang, I thought this was the song ranking XD