[quote name='zlilzlilzlil' post='61335' date='Mar 2 2009, 03:18 PM']This is so bad, even Mano Erina in better then them (and I think she is really bad, she is the worst thing ever in H!P in my opinion)...
This is just stupid to put a 6 and 8 years old childs on themself, the reason C-ute and Berryz Koubou did well is because they had years of practice before debuting, and risako (the youngest in BK) was 10 when the group debut, Mai (the youngest in C-ute) was 10 also when C-ute debuted (two years later, she joined H!P at the age of 6), but still the had people with them that wer'e bigger, and on their first singles (more about BK) Tsunku would have been heard better then the girl that sing the solo...
When they started the song they were off key, even koharu and sayumi before they got in MM knew how to sing in key, but they both sang off key, and they aren't singing they screaming the words, I'm starting to hate many things in H!P when I tought H!P is amazing...
I got sad...
By the way, I'm not cursing any one or insulting any one, I'm just saying it's not normal and it's not responsable to debut 2 girls that can't sing on the right key, with the music on, give them a year of practice or more and then we'll see, even miki fujimoto trained for a year before debuting solo...[/quote]
You can't be fucking serious. Really? Really? Are you really so upset that a 6 and 8 year old with no vocal training can't sing a song on key? Really? And you're comparing them to girls in their teens who've had months/years of vocal training? Really? Do you think a normal child can sing a song like Chance on key? With no training? Really?
Also, Koharu and Sayu were very much tone deaf before they entered MM. See:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rm4bFAfdS-s
I can't find a Sayu video from her audition but believe me, she was bad.
I honestly can't believe that people still get upset when girls who can't sing join H!P. Especially children. With the exception of 1st gen MM and soloists, singing talent has never been a big factor in auditions, considering the outcomes most of the time.
I don't even understand. I can see the point of not liking this because they're too young, but because of their musical talent? And you're starting to hate H!P just now because of these two not being able to sing? Have you seen any auditions before this?
I'm sorry for being a dickhead, but really, there's so much wrong with that post, and general thought of people being surprised at girls with little singing talent joining H!P is really grating. Charisma and looks go way further than musical talent in the idol world nowadays. If you really need generally good singers, then find an actual singer to enjoy.