Kind of a current H!P purist right now, so:
1. Buono!
2. C-ute
3. Berryz Kobo
4. Morning Musume
Mano and S/mileage are still fairly new so I'm giving them time to show what they can do.
H!P historical group ranking.
Moderators: testacles_4, Shoujo Q, momoirosaya
Re: H!P historical group ranking.
So Hangry & Angry don't count, right?
1. Morning Musume Despite 10+ years of whining and bitching, the flagship group is still the one that I'm most fond of.
2/3 tie. Buono! Arguably one of the best groups, despite their anime-tie in. They basically took the 3 of the most talented, popular and/or "charistmatic" H!P kids and gave them great, upbeat song and a VERY cute image change.
2/3 tie. Country Musume One of my favorite groups of all time and how I loved Rinne. Even the inclusion of Rika wasn't too bad - it lead to lots of chicken jokes and the song "Byebye Saigo no Yoru."
4. Pucchi Moni First generation Pucchi-Moni wins out over second generation, but both incarnations had the most fun songs and PVs. I used to exercise to their album "Zenbu Petit Moni"!! Also, Pittari X-mas and Chokotto Love have pretty much never left my mp3 playlist.
5. 3-nin Matsuri...does that count? I know it was a one time deal but it was a cute explosion. I first learned about Matsuura (in her cute and fun years) through this PV.
6. Tanpopo This is placed so low because 3 gen Tanpopo had Risa and the most ANNOYING PV for Be Happy. Of course, I love them otherwise.
7. Berryz The first time I paid attention to any of the kids! It was years and going "awww" and enjoying the songs, despite the shittiness of their collective vocal ability.
1. Morning Musume Despite 10+ years of whining and bitching, the flagship group is still the one that I'm most fond of.
2/3 tie. Buono! Arguably one of the best groups, despite their anime-tie in. They basically took the 3 of the most talented, popular and/or "charistmatic" H!P kids and gave them great, upbeat song and a VERY cute image change.
2/3 tie. Country Musume One of my favorite groups of all time and how I loved Rinne. Even the inclusion of Rika wasn't too bad - it lead to lots of chicken jokes and the song "Byebye Saigo no Yoru."
4. Pucchi Moni First generation Pucchi-Moni wins out over second generation, but both incarnations had the most fun songs and PVs. I used to exercise to their album "Zenbu Petit Moni"!! Also, Pittari X-mas and Chokotto Love have pretty much never left my mp3 playlist.
5. 3-nin Matsuri...does that count? I know it was a one time deal but it was a cute explosion. I first learned about Matsuura (in her cute and fun years) through this PV.
6. Tanpopo This is placed so low because 3 gen Tanpopo had Risa and the most ANNOYING PV for Be Happy. Of course, I love them otherwise.
7. Berryz The first time I paid attention to any of the kids! It was years and going "awww" and enjoying the songs, despite the shittiness of their collective vocal ability.
-
troubleshoot
- Kenshuusei
- Posts: 3
- Joined: Tue Sep 19, 2006 11:04 am
Re: H!P historical group ranking.
Morning Musume
Tanpopo
W
Minimoni
Country Musume
MKB
Petit Moni
The kids are booooorrrriiiinnnnngggg.
Tanpopo
W
Minimoni
Country Musume
MKB
Petit Moni
The kids are booooorrrriiiinnnnngggg.
Last edited by troubleshoot on Wed Mar 03, 2010 2:34 pm, edited 1 time in total.